Technical Articles
Rearchitecting SAP BusinessObjects to the Cloud – Options for SAP BusinessObjects Enterprise customers leading into 2027
The most recent SAP Analytics Business Intelligence Statement of Direction (SoD) clearly positions SAP Analytics Cloud as the strategic analytics platform. Yet the same SoD also outlines SAP’s commitment to existing SAP BusinessObjects customers. “We have delivered major innovations with the BI 4.3 release and the Support Pack 1, and will continue to enhance BI 4.3 on premise until the end of maintenance in 2027”
The same Statement of Direction also gives more clarity for SAP BusinessObjects customers on the plans for SAP BusinessObjects when it reaches end of priority one support in 2027. The SoD states that the product will then evolve into a managed cloud subscription only, as part of the SAP BusinessObjects Enterprise, Private Cloud Edition (BOE PCE). Available today, BOE PCE allows more and more of our customers to shift their on-premise workloads to a managed cloud environment and will continue to evolve and be supported beyond 2027..
The core message is that only companies that have migrated their on-premise BusinessObjects landscape to BOE PCE will continue to benefit from support and new functionalities beyond 2027.
SAP BusinessObjects Enterprise – End of Mainstream Maintenance
2027 may seem a long way off but the end of mainstream maintenance for BOE4.3 on-premise is just 4 years away. The diagram below explains that if you are still using BOE4.2 there will be a need to upgrade to BOE4.3 by the end of next year (2022) to remain fully supported as support will be given only for ‘Priority 1’ cases in 2023 and 2024.
Options for BOBJ customers to remain in support beyond 2025.
The opportunity is there for you
These End of maintenance dates and the release of BOE PCE do however give a great opportunity to review your SAP Analytics strategy and consider rearchitecting SAP BusinessObjects to the Cloud.
- Migrate BOE on-premise to BOE Private Cloud Edition
- Move Use cases to SAP Analytics Cloud
- Hybrid PCE & SAC
Migrate to BOE Private Cloud Edition
Considerations:
- Users can continue to use existing content in the product your users know
- BOE PCE is SAP Managed Cloud Infrastructure
- BOE 4.3 is Support beyond 2027 on BOE PCE with Annual Service Packs
- BOE PCE is the full SAP BusinessObjects Enterprise Edition
- BOE PCE can be hosted on hyperscaler of choice
- Customers have the opportunity to “Right Size” the landscape & subscription licensing
- Migration and Advisory services are not included to move existing on-premise content into the BusinessObjects PCE landscape.
- BOE in PCE is installed on Linux so there are a few subtle configuration differences
Move Use cases to SAP Analytics Cloud
Considerations:
- SAC is BI, Predictive & Planning in one place
- SAC is where Innovation is happening and the strategic analytics tool from SAP
- SAC is a SaaS with Subscription licensing
- SAC has both Public and Private tenant options
- SAC has Quarterly release cycle of new features deployed for you in your tenant
- Augmented BI with Smart Features
- SAC includes predefined content for many industries and lines of busines
- There is no migration tool to move BOE content to SAC and depending on use case SAC may not be a 1:2:1 replacement for Web Intelligence.
Hybrid PCE & SAC
Considerations:
- A hybrid approach can be the start of a cloud Analytics journey with SAP
- You get the best of both Worlds for as long as you need.
- A hybrid approach means you have SAP Managed Cloud Infrastructure for both applications and therefore reduced costs of maintenance and patching
- There is an opportunity to transition from Webi to SAC over time by changing the mix of licenses as you need
Journey with SAP Analytics – One Price, One Cloud Contract
If we step back and look at the costs of an on-premise software implementation, it not just simply the annual maintenance. It’s also Hardware, Hardware refreshes, software patching & upgrades but also people and processes.
Business Objects Private Cloud Edition is a fully managed SaaS that can be wrapped up into one cloud contract alongside SAP Analytics Cloud with a mix of licenses that can flex over the duration of a contract using either Swap Rights or a Phased Agreement.
This approach can enable companies to Right Size their current BOE implementation be that the number of licenses used and the BOE applications deployed. You can get the best of both applications for as long as you need and can transition from Webi to SAC by changing the mix of licenses over time.
In conclusion
There is an immediate opportunity for companies to reconsider their SAP Analytics strategy and avoid regret costs migrating from 4.2 to 4.3 on-premise in 2022 but consider a future hybrid landscape implementing SAP BusinessObjects Enterprise, Private Cloud Edition and SAP Analytics Cloud, side by side.
To learn more, join us on September 23 @ 11:00am ET | 5:00pm CET for our Q3 #askSAP Analytics call on “SAP BusinessObjects BI 4.3 SP02 + Options on the Journey to the Cloud”.
Link: https://event.on24.com/wcc/r/3374541/D5F4B69D895A186C5E0ABD1584EA0B75?partnerref=Afblog
Hi
Thank you for your post. But i think you made a mistake about Lumira Designer. It is included
Thanks Michael, let me double check.
Hello Andrew
Thanks for the post. I have a question about the SAP strategy.
We are SAP BO Partner for more than 15 years.
We have a quite number of customer with the following architecture based on SAP BO Edge:
We build the DWH with SAP Dataservice, Universe and Webireports
So there is a SAP BO Enterpirse in the cloud, but without Dataservice and Database.
What is the SAP Migration Strategie in this case.
Looking forward to your anwser
Thanks
Beat
Hello Beat
Currently, 3 possibilities :
1- move everything to SAC (I know what you will tell me)
2- Keep 1 Bobj license to use DI and IQ and the rest moves to BOBJ PCE accessing to onprem data
3- Use DS PCE and move your data to HANA Cloud (expensive though)
florian
Hi Andrew,
SAP SAC Does not come up with " out of the box " two factor authentication (2FA)
What options are available with BOE PCE and what prevents the BOE PCE URL being called from outside a corporate domain ?
Thanks
Tony
Hi Tony Hayes
i had a quick look at the SAC influence portal, and found this entry https://influence.sap.com/sap/ino/#/idea/263008
to quote the feedback there that: "MFA with Default Identity Provider isn't supported" .. The product manager responded (for SAC) that:
<< This can be implemented using the IDPs surrounding SAP Analytics Cloud, for example via SAP IAS (2FA).>>
My experience with my own customers is that - once they switch off SAC from the default SAP-provided Cloud Identity provider, and use their own custom IDP and at that stage 2 factor authentication is a mechanism that the integration into their existing IT landscape will need to provide.
Regards, H
Thanks Henry for the prompt reply.
Tony
How will SAP deliver same response times when BOE on-premise will have to move to SAP Private cloud hosting setup?
On premise BOE are typically hosted in same data center as DB Tier (SAP/non SAP). Adding small latency (and I am being optimistic here) will result in considerable run time degradation as applications like Analysis for OLAP, Lumira via BICS or HTTP INA produce a lot of requests for single navigation action (refresh, prompt, LOV fetch). Secondly BI4.3 will provide richer interface so again traffic between Web Application and business users be impacted to build UI in local browser.
Before you dismiss our concerns we have done in depth analysis on this aspect my measuring the impact of moving BOE tier to different hosting setup. For relational workflows the difference was small but any workflows via JCO BICS or HTTP INA showed degradation in performance.
Way forward is the optimize the interface aspect between application and DB tier to be less network chatty, same applies for SAC with live connection for that matter.
Regards
Johann K, Martin M
M. Draghi,
Thanks for your feedback and I will share this with the BOE product management team.