Skip to Content
Personal Insights
Author's profile photo Jerry Janda

Manoj Khavatkopp — Member of the Month, March 2019

People often ask me how a Member of the Month is chosen.

OK, that’s a lie. People really don’t ask me that a lot. Which is good, because I wouldn’t want to admit to the bribery involved…

OK, that’s a lie too. Numbers are involved, but not in a monetary sort of way.

In each month’s introductions, I’ll usually mention a person’s contributions — dozens of blogs of this, hundreds of answers that, and so on. But those types of numbers don’t tell the full story. If they did, I could answer a dozen random questions a day — amassing thousands within a year — which might be impressive, if not for the fact that I wouldn’t know what I was talking about, so all of my answers would be wrong.

Our reputation program rewards quality over quantity for a reason.

A member might catch attention for responding to a whole bunch of questions, but we’re most interested in how many answers get accepted, upvoted…and even downvoted. We also look at missions completed, badges earned, and general community response, to get a sense of whether a member’s contributions truly are helpful.

Which brings me to March’s Member of the Month: Manoj K.

Yep, Manoj meets the standard criteria for high activity: He’s answered more than five hundred questions. But what about community reaction? In terms of answers accepted, he’s at about a rate of 25% — a number that might seem low, until you consider that getting people to accept answers and close questions is an ongoing challenge (something I acknowledged last month). That’s why, in addition to counting accepted answers, we look at the number of upvotes: the community’s way of saying, “That’s right.” Manoj has plenty of those…and no downvotes.

Dive a little deeper — as I did — and you’ll unearth even more substance. I didn’t read all of Manoj’s answers, but picking a solid representation of his contributions randomly, I discovered a member (of the month) willing to discuss problems patiently. I saw several conversations in the comments in which Manoj did his best to guide posters. Plenty of times he provided screen shots along with detailed instructions to assist fellow members. Heck, he even did the searches that the posters probably should have done themselves, pointing to SAP Community blog posts and answers with the right solutions — and never with a snide crack to go with the link.

I was also happy to see Manoj often involved in the same threads with other members in the Hall of Fame as they tried to help someone looking for more information. It pleases me when the best members travel in the same circles (or, in this case, side by side in comments and answers).

Makes me wonder if they’ve made a connection — a sort of informal Member of the Month club. That would be cool.

Guess I should ask Manoj…

Congratulations, Manoj! How’s it going?

Well I was really surprised to see your message after coming back from vacation. A great welcome back from vacation. Thanks again!

You’re welcome…and I hope you enjoyed your vacation. But now that it’s back to work, I see from your profile that you work for Deloitte. Is that accurate? If so, what is your position there? 

Yes, I am currently working in Deloitte as an integration consultant, mainly on SAP PI/PO and CPI.

What did you do before joining Deloitte?

I graduated in computer science in 2013. I joined Accenture as an ABAP consultant in my early days, then I switched to integration platform, which I am much more interested in. Now I have been with Deloitte for the past two years.

When and why did you join the community?

I joined the community in 2014, when I was put as an integration consultant role in a project. At that time, I had no idea what SAP PI/PO was about. But thanks to the community members, they made my life easy at this early stage of learning by answering every question in detailed manner, which could be understood by any beginner.


Manoj Khavatkopp. Integration consultant. Traveler. Member of the Month for March.


How did you develop your areas of expertise?

As said, I had started my SAP journey as an ABAP consultant, but being from a computer science background, I was much more interested in Java. That is when I decided to switch to process integration and orchestration.

Here’s the big question: How do you find the time to answer so many questions? On top of that, how do you find the time to provide all the details — and, in some cases, search for the answers on behalf of the poster?

I try to check the community at least once a day, either during working hours as and when I get time or some time on the way back to home. The reason why I like to check is that there is always a new question/blog which helps myself to try it out and help in learning. So helping other community members is helping myself for self-learning. As Eng Swee Yeoh has mentioned, “The true value of this community is in its people.”

When looking look through your answer and comment threads, I saw two familiar names: Harish Mistri and Evgeniy Kolmakov, both of whom also received the Member of the Month honor. I even saw them responding to some of your questions during your early days with the community. Have you ever spoken to them about your shared areas of professional interest?

Harish and Evgeniy have been helping from my initial days of SCN till now. I always get to learn something new from them as and when I interact with them on any query/comment. And also I would like to thank Hareesh Gampa (with whom I have worked closely on one of the projects) and Eng Swee Yeoh and Vadim Klimov for their wonderful blogs and out-of-box solutions.

OK, we’ve already established how busy you are, but I assume work and SAP Community don’t consume your every waking moment. What do you like to do when you aren’t working?

I am mostly into traveling or gaming when I am not working.

And with that, I should let you get back to work — and/or answering member questions. Thanks for all you do for SAP Community — and congrats again on being Member of the Month for March!

Thanks again to my peer members for helping me from my early days to reach Member of the Month.

Assigned Tags

      You must be Logged on to comment or reply to a post.
      Author's profile photo Harish Mistri
      Harish Mistri

      Congratulation Manoj !!! nice to know about you !!

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Harish 🙂

      Author's profile photo Jeremy Good
      Jeremy Good

      Congrats Manoj - welcome to the formal MoM club 🙂

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Jeremy 🙂

      Author's profile photo Eng Swee Yeoh
      Eng Swee Yeoh

      Congrats Manoj K !

      I indeed remember the early days when you started getting involved in the community, looking for answers and learning wherever you can. And look at you now - being the one who guide those who are like you in the past.


      A well deserved recognition indeed. Kudos and keep up the good work.


      P/S: And thanks for the shout out too 😉

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Eng Swee for your continuous support 🙂

      Author's profile photo Dilip Kumar Krishnadev Pandey
      Dilip Kumar Krishnadev Pandey

      Congratulations Manoj K !! .......and I'm surprised too to know that this type of recognition exits ........

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Dilip 🙂

      Author's profile photo Evgeniy Kolmakov
      Evgeniy Kolmakov

      Hi Manoj!

      Congratulations! Glad to welcome you in the MOMs club :-).

      Thank you very much for your kind words! I have always been paying attention to your answers and comments. I often find lots of helpfull information there.

      Regards, Evgeniy.

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Eve for your continuous help 🙂

      Author's profile photo rahul kumar
      rahul kumar

      Congrats Manoj ............ 🙂

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Rahul 🙂

      Author's profile photo Mahesh Palavalli
      Mahesh Palavalli

      Congrats Manoj K 🙂

      Awesome introduction part Jerry Janda,  I always have this smile on me when I read your blogs 😀 they are very funny and a good read (especially the introduction part 🙂 🙂 )


      Best Regards,


      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Mahesh 🙂

      Author's profile photo Jerry Janda
      Jerry Janda
      Blog Post Author

      Thanks, Mahesh! I'm glad you enjoy them (and thanks for reading my posts). 🙂

      Author's profile photo Nabheet Madan
      Nabheet Madan

      Congrats Manoj well deserved and well done!

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Nabheet 🙂

      Author's profile photo Lakshmipathi Ganesan
      Lakshmipathi Ganesan


      Congratulations Manoj for the contributions you have been giving and keep continuing.  By the way, I have a question to SCN team and Jerry Janda that whatever missions being introduced by SCN, while members try to achieve various missions, from SCN side, what follow up action is being initiated.

      The reason for asking this is in your post, you have mentioned the below

      and being a Moderator, I have been watching lot of discussions where members gave quality suggestions but neither the suggestion is up voted nor properly recognized by clicking "Right Answer".

      In fact, couple of years ago, SCN have delegated an exercise to Moderators to look into non-Answered discussions and we have been asked to respond based on which, SCN would do a follow up activity.  But the fact was I did give solution to more than such 500 open questions and since there was no response from any of the OPs, I brought this to the attention of SCN team but unfortunately, I have not got proper feedback.

      What I would like to highlight is if any member who creates a discussion, got feedback and if there is no response for a period of time (say one month), it is SCN's duty to remind the OP to look into the suggestions they got, update the discussion whether the issue is addressed or not.  Only by this way, many more such SCN members would be recognized.





      Author's profile photo Jerry Janda
      Jerry Janda
      Blog Post Author

      This is an ongoing issue and one that has been discussed several times throughout the community. I can think of a couple conversations about this topic in the Coffee Corner alone. I also acknowledged the issue in my introduction.

      We always encourage posters to accept correct answers and close questions, but we can't force them. So while it's unfortunate that active members don't always get the recognition that they deserve (and that includes you, and we are grateful for all of your contributions), it's not something easily addressed. Even sending reminders won't bring back posters who lose interest after their questions are answered. (Upvoting is an entirely different thing and is completely at the discretion of community members.)

      All of that being said, we continue to look for solutions to make sure answers are accepted and questions closed. For now, I take some comfort in knowing that I (and I believe others) don't use the numbers as the only measure of a member's worth. Just look at Manoj. That 25% acceptance rate doesn't do him justice (a point I emphasized in the opening), but we can see past the statistics to recognize his importance to the community -- which is why we're celebrating him in this blog post. Even if we weren't, the community always finds a way to thank those who make a difference. Manoj did it here -- showing his appreciation for those who assisted him. And those whom he assisted are offering their congratulations. I love seeing that.

      Author's profile photo Srinivas Karnam
      Srinivas Karnam

      Congrats Manoj !!

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Srinivas 🙂

      Author's profile photo Pavan Kumar
      Pavan Kumar

      Congratulations  Manoj, Thanks for your contribution.

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Pavan!

      Author's profile photo Niladri Bihari Nayak
      Niladri Bihari Nayak

      Congrats Manoj ! Keep it up...

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thank you 🙂

      Author's profile photo Muni M
      Muni M

      Congrats Manoj!!!

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Muni 🙂

      Author's profile photo Joao Sousa
      Joao Sousa

      Congratulations fellow Deloittian! 😉

      Author's profile photo Sarbjeet Singh
      Sarbjeet Singh

      Congratulations Manoj. 🙂 All the best for future.

      Author's profile photo aliha karang
      aliha karang

      congratulation bro.. succes always..

      Author's profile photo Rakesh damera
      Rakesh damera

      I have had the privilege of working with Manoj and am not surprised by this recognition. He is  just amazing with he does and definitely an asset to any team in my opinion. Keep rocking Manoj!

      Author's profile photo Manoj K
      Manoj K

      Thanks Rakesh 🙂

      Author's profile photo venkata Sridhar Naidu chukka
      venkata Sridhar Naidu chukka

      Congrats Manoj.. its really great to see to you reach here .

      Author's profile photo tdc indonesia
      tdc indonesia

      congrats brother, it really easy for you aplication it..

      Author's profile photo Former Member
      Former Member

      congrats major for sharing education, i think very good..

      Author's profile photo agung podomoro
      agung podomoro

      yeah, congrats major brother. I think this application perfect..

      Author's profile photo Hydeliving Interior
      Hydeliving Interior

      congrast my brother.. Are you so Good..