If so, you need SAP Universal ID. In a few months, SAP Universal ID will be the only option to login to SAP Community. Without it, you will lose your content and badges. If you have multiple accounts, use the Consolidation Tool to merge your content.
For me this come just a t the right time, as I have to look into S/4HANA Extensibility soon - good thing I can do this using the newest whitepaper now!
A small peace of feedback (which I might have given in the past already, not entirely sure about it) and wish for improvement:
When using the download link (at the bottom of the page), the filename is kind of cryptic: 2ad59b27-347c-0010-82c7-eda71af511fa.pdf
It would be nice if it could be something more telling, like "S4HANA Extensibility Whitepaper 09_2018 Update.pdf" instead!
So Thomas, does this mean that "Managed Extensibility" has been removed to the roadmap now ? And if yes, any alternative is provided for partner add-ons or that option is now excluded from the future roadmap ?
“Managed Extensibility” has been removed already in the previous (2016) version of the whte paper. For partners, refer to Chapter 4. Unfortunately, as stated in the document, a fixed road map for the feature mentioned therein is not yet available.
As I'm going through it, here's another piece of feedback:
5.1.1.2. Recommendations
In general, if multiple options are available for your enhancement use case, choose the following,
shown in order of preference, for new implementations:
New BAdIs for SAP S/4HANA
Explicit enhancement options, user or system exits, or application-specific enhancement frameworks
Explicit enhancement options
Modifications of SAP code
Clone and adoption of SAP code
I guess the 2nd occurrence of "Explicit enhancement options" is meant to say "implicit enhancement options" instead, right?! (Otherwise, why wouldn’t they be mentioned at all?)
got it, but maybe you can forward my feedback (also the one with the filename) to the owner!?
Or let me know the (user) name, the I can @-Mention her or him directly?!
I got another one here:
On page 31, there are some links-
On is titled
"ABAP extensibility community on SAP Community"
and links to
https://www.sap.com/community/topic/abap-extensibility.html
However, this is redirected to a generic
https://www.sap.com/community/topics.html
are there plans for an update of the White Paper? With the closer integration of SAP Cloud Application Programming Model (CAP) and SAP Cloud SDK I think an update would make sense.
Thanks a lot, Thomas!
For me this come just a t the right time, as I have to look into S/4HANA Extensibility soon - good thing I can do this using the newest whitepaper now!
A small peace of feedback (which I might have given in the past already, not entirely sure about it) and wish for improvement:
When using the download link (at the bottom of the page), the filename is kind of cryptic: 2ad59b27-347c-0010-82c7-eda71af511fa.pdf
It would be nice if it could be something more telling, like "S4HANA Extensibility Whitepaper 09_2018 Update.pdf" instead!
best
Joachim
So Thomas, does this mean that "Managed Extensibility" has been removed to the roadmap now ? And if yes, any alternative is provided for partner add-ons or that option is now excluded from the future roadmap ?
“Managed Extensibility” has been removed already in the previous (2016) version of the whte paper. For partners, refer to Chapter 4. Unfortunately, as stated in the document, a fixed road map for the feature mentioned therein is not yet available.
As I'm going through it, here's another piece of feedback:
I guess the 2nd occurrence of "Explicit enhancement options" is meant to say "implicit enhancement options" instead, right?! (Otherwise, why wouldn’t they be mentioned at all?)
best
Joachim
Hi Joachim,
I am not the owner of the document, but I agree that this must be a typo.
Best regards,
Thomas
.
Hi Thomas,
got it, but maybe you can forward my feedback (also the one with the filename) to the owner!?
Or let me know the (user) name, the I can @-Mention her or him directly?!
I got another one here:
On page 31, there are some links-
On is titled
"ABAP extensibility community on SAP Community"
and links to
https://www.sap.com/community/topic/abap-extensibility.html
However, this is redirected to a generic
https://www.sap.com/community/topics.html
thanks
Joachim
Hi Joachim,
I try to identify the owner and forward the feedback.
Best regards, Thomas
Why is SAP CP Rapid Application Development by Mendix not mentioned as an option to develop side-by-side extensions?
Rgds,
Jeroen
Hi Thomas,
I see the white paper mentions Node Extensibility as in the Roadmap.
Is there a target release for this feature ?
Thanks in advance.
Regards,
Helder
Hi Helder, there is no target release yet. Best regards, Thomas
All, do you know about the SAP S/4HANA Cloud Extensibility Explorer yet? https://extensibilityexplorer.cfapps.eu10.hana.ondemand.com/ExtensibilityExplorer/
Dear Thomas,
are there plans for an update of the White Paper? With the closer integration of SAP Cloud Application Programming Model (CAP) and SAP Cloud SDK I think an update would make sense.
Best regards
Gregor
Unfortunately I cannot comment on this. Best regards, Thomas