Skip to Content
Author's profile photo Sibo Zhang

Consolidation feature difference across BPC NW versions

Standard Model 10.0 Standard Model 10.1 Embedded Model 10.1 Embedded Model in 1605 – Simple Finance Embedded Model
in 1610
S4HANA – RTC
Platform NW 730/740 NW 740/750/751 NW740 SP14/NW 750 SP02 NW 750 SP05 NW 751 SP00
Consolidation Monitor Standard Standard Enhanced Enhanced Enhanced
Ownership Ownership Manager Ownership Manager

Ownership

Manager

Ownership
Manager
Ownership Manager
Ownership Calculation Ownership Calculation Ownership Calculation Ownership Calculation
Control Control Monitor Control Monitor No Control Monitor Control Monitor
Control Report Control Report Control Report Control Report
Journal Standard Standard Standard Multiple Journal template Multiple Journal template
Business Rules  Elimination and Adjustment  Elimination and Adjustment  Elimination
and
Adjustment
 Elimination
and
Adjustment
 Elimination and Adjustment
 Currency Conversion  Currency Conversion  Currency Conversion  Currency Conversion  Currency Conversion
 Balance Carry Forward  Balance Carry Forward  Balance Carry Forward  Balance Carry Forward  Balance Carry Forward
 IC Data & IC Matching  IC Data & IC Matching  IC Data & IC Matching  IC Data & IC Matching  IC Data & IC Matching
 Account Transformation  Account Transformation  Account Transformation  Account Transformation  Account Transformation
 US Elimination  US Elimination
 Equity Pick Up
Currency Conversion Options BPC BPC BPC BPC BPC and ECC
Matrix Consolidation No Yes No No No
Parallel Consolidation No Yes No No No
Incremental Consolidation Yes Yes No No No
YTD Consolidation Yes Yes No No No
Real time read/write with S/4HANA No No No Yes – Reading Yes – Reading & Writing
Modeling BPC Web BPC Web BPC Web/RSPLAN
/RSA1
BPC Web/RSPLAN
/RSA1
BPC Web/RSPLAN
/RSA1/S4/HANA studio
Reporting tool EPM Add in EPM Add in Analysis for Office Analysis for Office Analysis for Office
Source of actual Cube Cube Cube/Direct Update DSO Cube/Direct Update DSO/ACDOCA Cube/Direct Update DSO/ACDOCA
Consolidated storage Cube Cube Cube/Direct Update DSO Cube/Direct Update DSO Cube/Direct Update DSO
/ACDOCC table
Transport Yes Yes Below are not transportable

  • Business rule definition
  • Control rule definition
  • Journal template definition
  • Task sequence definition
Below are not transportable

  • Business rule definition
  • Control rule definition
  • Journal template definition
  • Task sequence definition
Below are not transportable

  • Business rule definition
  • Control rule definition
  • Journal template definition
  • Task sequence definition

 

Assigned Tags

      4 Comments
      You must be Logged on to comment or reply to a post.
      Author's profile photo Lucas Gabriel
      Lucas Gabriel

      Nice table!

      I'd just add one feature to RTC that is Currency Translation in S/4 option.

      Author's profile photo Sibo Zhang
      Sibo Zhang
      Blog Post Author

       

      Thanks for the suggestion! Table updated.

      Author's profile photo Syed Siraj
      Syed Siraj

      Is this the updated table? because we are deciding to perform consolidation. we are currently on ERP and moving on s/4 hana. which version of BPC 10.1 is suitable for consolidation. at this point of time we have to perform consolidation for 25 entities with complex requirements. any suggestion ?

      Author's profile photo ManishKumar Jain
      ManishKumar Jain

      Hi,

      You should add FC and Group reporting comparison next to this and a new comparison suggesting the positioning and strategic choice for consolidation going forward.

       

      Regards,

      Manish