Consolidation feature difference across BPC NW versions
| Standard Model 10.0 | Standard Model 10.1 | Embedded Model 10.1 | Embedded Model in 1605 – Simple Finance | Embedded Model in 1610 S4HANA – RTC |
|
| Platform | NW 730/740 | NW 740/750/751 | NW740 SP14/NW 750 SP02 | NW 750 SP05 | NW 751 SP00 |
| Consolidation Monitor | Standard | Standard | Enhanced | Enhanced | Enhanced |
| Ownership | Ownership Manager | Ownership Manager |
Ownership Manager |
Ownership Manager |
Ownership Manager |
| Ownership Calculation | Ownership Calculation | Ownership Calculation | Ownership Calculation | ||
| Control | Control Monitor | Control Monitor | No | Control Monitor | Control Monitor |
| Control Report | Control Report | Control Report | Control Report | ||
| Journal | Standard | Standard | Standard | Multiple Journal template | Multiple Journal template |
| Business Rules | Elimination and Adjustment | Elimination and Adjustment | Elimination and Adjustment |
Elimination and Adjustment |
Elimination and Adjustment |
| Currency Conversion | Currency Conversion | Currency Conversion | Currency Conversion | Currency Conversion | |
| Balance Carry Forward | Balance Carry Forward | Balance Carry Forward | Balance Carry Forward | Balance Carry Forward | |
| IC Data & IC Matching | IC Data & IC Matching | IC Data & IC Matching | IC Data & IC Matching | IC Data & IC Matching | |
| Account Transformation | Account Transformation | Account Transformation | Account Transformation | Account Transformation | |
| US Elimination | US Elimination | ||||
| Equity Pick Up | |||||
| Currency Conversion Options | BPC | BPC | BPC | BPC | BPC and ECC |
| Matrix Consolidation | No | Yes | No | No | No |
| Parallel Consolidation | No | Yes | No | No | No |
| Incremental Consolidation | Yes | Yes | No | No | No |
| YTD Consolidation | Yes | Yes | No | No | No |
| Real time read/write with S/4HANA | No | No | No | Yes – Reading | Yes – Reading & Writing |
| Modeling | BPC Web | BPC Web | BPC Web/RSPLAN /RSA1 |
BPC Web/RSPLAN /RSA1 |
BPC Web/RSPLAN /RSA1/S4/HANA studio |
| Reporting tool | EPM Add in | EPM Add in | Analysis for Office | Analysis for Office | Analysis for Office |
| Source of actual | Cube | Cube | Cube/Direct Update DSO | Cube/Direct Update DSO/ACDOCA | Cube/Direct Update DSO/ACDOCA |
| Consolidated storage | Cube | Cube | Cube/Direct Update DSO | Cube/Direct Update DSO | Cube/Direct Update DSO |
| /ACDOCC table | |||||
| Transport | Yes | Yes | Below are not transportable
|
Below are not transportable
|
Below are not transportable
|
Nice table!
I'd just add one feature to RTC that is Currency Translation in S/4 option.
Thanks for the suggestion! Table updated.
Is this the updated table? because we are deciding to perform consolidation. we are currently on ERP and moving on s/4 hana. which version of BPC 10.1 is suitable for consolidation. at this point of time we have to perform consolidation for 25 entities with complex requirements. any suggestion ?
Hi,
You should add FC and Group reporting comparison next to this and a new comparison suggesting the positioning and strategic choice for consolidation going forward.
Regards,
Manish