Skip to Content
Author's profile photo Gabriella Gogl-Gyorgy

„Can you please help me answer my question?” – The new era of Q&A on the new #1DXCOMMDEST

Hey All!

We all heard that question a billion times in the Community, right? This is what usually happens:

  1. Jack raises a question and asks for help.
  2. The Community experts provide an answer.
  3. Everyone is happy and the question gets closed and forgotten.
  4. Then Jill comes to the Community and asks the very same question again, because she failed to search or just got lost in the information jungle and didn’t find the answer.

This is soon to be over.

In an ideal world, Jill would have found the answer before raising the question again. Let’s see how the new SAP Q&A platform will help us reach that.

The new beginning

When we launch the new Community, the Q&A platform will have a fresh start, meaning that it’s up to you to populate it with content.

Wait, what? What happens to the answers and knowledge we gathered in the last years?

We’ll keep them in an archived read-only format that will surface in the Community in various ways.Where exactly?

First (and in my opinion the most important one) when someone wants to create a new question and starts typing, it will trigger a search in the archive for similar topics. Questioners will then have the ability to find the answer before posting the question. There are a lot of questions raised on SCN that get reported because the people who asked them did not perform a search in the existing knowledge base prior to posting. This creates duplicate posts and unnecessary abuse reports for Moderators. Our goal is to reduce these instances and provide a clean and up to date knowledge base at hand.

Also, still sticking to the topic of search, the Community discussions that get archived will appear in the global 1DX search as well. So these discussions can surface anywhere on, including full text and the archived tags that were assigned to them.

And of course you will always have the possibility to check the archive if you need something or want to browse.

Since we want to provide a clean and useful database, some of the discussions/questions will be deleted:

  • Questions that do not have any comments or answers.
  • Questions that belong to spaces that have been deleted.
  • Questions that have been hidden as a result of an abuse report.

So that’s all about the past, now let’s see what our future holds.

Answers… answers everywhere

Our team strives for providing a pleasant Q&A experience by following a similar concept like stackoverflow.

To make the given answers more transparent there will be only one that can be marked as accepted for the question. But if you realize that another answer is better, as the original poster you can change which one you want to highlight as the best one.

We’d also like to provide an opportunity for good answers climb to the top. As a general community member you can help decide whether an answer is useful or not and vote it up or down. Items having the most votes will appear on the top to help us to find information faster.

Trusted Members

Since we all love our Community and want to improve the way we engage, our new platform will enable users to gain additional privileges in respect to their level of participation. For instance, meeting a particular set of criteria will unlock another level of governance in SCN. This will allow members to play a leadership role in the Community while encouraging positive behavior and higher quality content.

What happens if the same question gets asked twice?

Ideally this shouldn’t happen, but if someone could not find an already existing answer, there is a possibility for moderators to redirect the duplicated question. This means that if a member wants to access the newly added (but repeat) question, they will be automatically redirected to the first one where they can find the answer. If the second asker is not happy with the first answer, they can decide to keep their question and specify or describe better why it hasn’t been answered or they can continue the conversation.

Hope You enjoyed the sneak-peek about SAP Q&A. More info to come, so stay tuned!

1DX rocks! 🙂


Assigned Tags

      You must be Logged on to comment or reply to a post.
      Author's profile photo Steve Rumsby
      Steve Rumsby

      To make the given answers more transparent there will be only one that can be marked as accepted for the question.

      Is there going to be the concept of "helpful answer" as there is now? I've seen more than a few questions answers in several parts by several people contributing a piece of the puzzle. It would be a shame if only the final piece can be given credit as the answer.

      Author's profile photo Gabriella Gogl-Gyorgy
      Gabriella Gogl-Gyorgy
      Blog Post Author

      Hi Steve,

      As I wrote a paragraph later, good "helpful" answers will climb to the top by being voted up, so you can read answers in the default order of relevance and helpfulness.


      Author's profile photo Juwin Pallipat Thomas
      Juwin Pallipat Thomas

      I would love if the new SCN had a way to automatically block a person from posting more questions, if he hasn't closed his previous threads - many people just vanish after receiving answers and doesn't confirm if the solution worked for them or not.



      Author's profile photo Jelena Perfiljeva
      Jelena Perfiljeva

      Hopefully "searching while typing" will be faster than it currently works (or rather doesn't) for tags. Otherwise it'll be useless. Although I'm happy that people posting questions in the SD forum with title 'Pricing' will get their payback. 😈

      Author's profile photo Jim Spath
      Jim Spath

      Jelena Perfiljeva of course it will be fast; it will run on SAP HANA, right?

      "How fast" is a different story.

      Author's profile photo Jelena Perfiljeva
      Jelena Perfiljeva

      Jim, a subtle promo for your Fast is not a number blog, eh? 😉 Good times...

      Author's profile photo Jim Spath
      Jim Spath

      Metrics Я Us.

      Author's profile photo Former Member
      Former Member

      These are good news. I really hoped for a system like for the new SCN and now it seems we will get it. Great!

      Author's profile photo Juwin Pallipat Thomas
      Juwin Pallipat Thomas

      Is there any mobile app coming up for the new SCN? Or, is it already existing?


      Author's profile photo Juwin Pallipat Thomas
      Juwin Pallipat Thomas

      Hoping to see a new look with the new SCN. Currently, after a few replies to a thread, it looks like this....

      2015-08-13 12_06_10-Need to send xlsx email attachment in zip forma... _ SCN.jpg

      Author's profile photo Former Member
      Former Member

      You can set in your profile preferences the Discussion View Style to 'FLAT'. But yes, the whole thing needs to be much more user friendly.

      Author's profile photo Juwin Pallipat Thomas
      Juwin Pallipat Thomas

      That just takes out the vertical lines from the view. But, currently, those lines is the only thing which connects answers & questions. Without that view, I don't think anyone would be able to understand the context of each of the replies.



      Author's profile photo Renan Correa
      Renan Correa

      Hi Gabriella,

      What is going to happen with questions/discussions from a space like SPED & NF-e and SAP Community in Portuguese? Are they going to be deleted or not?


      Renan Correa

      Author's profile photo Gabriella Gogl-Gyorgy
      Gabriella Gogl-Gyorgy
      Blog Post Author

      Hi Renan,

      Others than the ones I listed above for deletion, everything will be put in the archive.



      Author's profile photo Ebrahim Hatem
      Ebrahim Hatem


      but some of them, they don't want to search, they want just ask and get an answer, what about this case?



      Author's profile photo Tom Cenens
      Tom Cenens

      Hi Ibrahim

      In my opinion that's bad practice really, just ask and not search. I've seen huge amounts of "easy" questions on SCN lately and that's a pity. Some are not even trying to do any research themselves and resort to what is seen as the easy way out, just ask and someone will give me the answer. That's not really adding value to the community in my opinion, it creates a lot of duplicate questions, irrelevant information / noise for those who are searching to solve more complex problems.

      I've seen community members go pretty far in this as well, as far as just dropping requirements online and expecting others to do their job for them basically. That kind of behavior makes me a little bit sad to be honest.

      The SCN Rules Of Engagement request nicely to search first:

      The SCN Rules of Engagement

      Best regards


      Author's profile photo Johan Hakkesteegt
      Johan Hakkesteegt

      Hi Tom,

      I am with you on this, but I do wonder how much this problem is not so black-and-white.

      In my experience there are not a few experts out there who will answer any and all questions, in the hope to score reputation points (hell, I have been guilty of this myself on occasion). No matter if they have answered the same question many times. In fact, currently this behavior is even rewarded. So the new system (as I understand it) would probably go a long way in solving this.

      On the other hand, gaining reputation points is what makes helping out, and answering questions worth while. I know that I for one will be a whole lot less inclined to visit the Q/A fora (or indeed SCN at all), if there are so few questions for me to answer, that the amount of reputation points to be gained on any given day dwindles to near zero.

      So my fear is, that although the new system will help in finding existing solutions (thus weeding out unnecessary questions and answers), it will hamper the creation of new ones, because experts may become proportionally less interested in providing help.



      Author's profile photo Gabriella Gogl-Gyorgy
      Gabriella Gogl-Gyorgy
      Blog Post Author


      Yes, we've all seen cases like that. I hope that the automatic search results popping into the user's face when typing in their new questions will reduce these. So it's really just one click away, but of course there'll be people who'll always ignore them.



      Author's profile photo Former Member
      Former Member

      This is exactly the reason why I never look in the discussion forums. Too many questions, without the slightest effort of own research and very often have nothing to do with the Space Topic at all. I really think there is a need for a system like Stackoverflow. This will improve the quality tremendously.

      Best regards, Tapio

      Author's profile photo Jürgen Lins
      Jürgen Lins

      What is this very special thing what Stackoverflow does?

      Is it the machine that automatically does something?

      Is it the negative evaluation that demotivates users to post questions?

      We have here the option for every user to alert the moderators for various reasons, failed to search is among them. We have as well the option to rate content. Both is not really used by our users.

      And if Stackoverflow also depends on users then with the platform change I still have the same users. I curious if that will change something.

      Author's profile photo Tom Cenens
      Tom Cenens

      Hi Jurgen

      There are systems where contribution matters in terms of how many question you can ask in a given time-span depends on how much you contribute yourself / quality of those contributions.

      What effects that would have is another question but it's interesting to see these different types of approaches.

      StackOverflow has some specifics to it. Time will tell how much SAP will try to reproduce:

      Best regards


      Author's profile photo Jürgen Lins
      Jürgen Lins

      Thanks, I had only read the German version of wikipedia and that information was not so detailed as the English.

      I have been at stack_overflow this morning and even before to get some impressions, but I am not yet convinced. I saw poor questions with a couple negative votes and I saw that they got their answers too. No difference so far to SCN.  The negative votes have to come from users, like the positive votes too. 

      How much moderator alerts do we have on a FAQ compared to answers? I often see already 10 answers to such questions but have just a single alert. Similar to super technical answers, maybe 2 or 3 likes over a couple years.

      I am not sure if our users here will change attitude with change of the platform.

      Maybe we moderators can then hide more behind technical settings instead of standing behind a human decision. We will see it soon, the jigsaw pieces are not put together yet, hard to imagine to full picture.

      Author's profile photo Sylwia Ganiec
      Sylwia Ganiec

      Great news!

      We have a similar tool to stackoverflow, a tool for an interactive Q&A community with gamified elements like badges, reputations. It is called hybris Experts and it runs on AnswerHub software.

      It is a great solution for reducing barriers between people, departments and companies. The hybris Experts community is mainly technical people ( hybris/SAP employees, partners, customers) who have unique questions about hybris/SAP products, that weren`t covered by the documentation.

      Author's profile photo Former Member
      Former Member

      Great news!!!

      Author's profile photo Parag Pandya
      Parag Pandya

      Hello Gabriella György,

      I must say that this is a wonder initiative take by you/your team and thank you very much for doing it for the betterment of members and newcomers to get the solution before they post.

      I know I am replying very late on this post but still I am having few suggestion in respect to this initiative allow me to put my thoughts across.

      Many times when I am searching for the solution of some issue I got lost in the information jungle. Very few times I get the proper or exact document which I was actually looking for. And then today when I read this I have understood that there are many people like me who face such problem.

      The First thought comes into my mind is “I wish I could get the result as per the section of topic“By stating section or Topic I am trying to say that SAP-SD covers so many topics like ie:

      Enterprise Structures

      Customer Master

      CMIR Master

      Material Master for SD

      Automatic Data Determination and Shipment Scheduling

      Collective Processing

      Availability Check

      Complaints Processing

      Lists and Analytics for Sales and Distribution Processes

      Sales Order Processing


      Third Party Sales


      Inter Company


      Sales Document Customizing

      Data Flow

      Special Business Processes

      Incomplete Documents

      Business Partners

      Outline Agreements

      Material Determination

      Material Listing and Exclusion

      Free Goods

      Delivery Document Process

      Transportation and Shipment

      Routes and Legs

      Controlling Deliveries

      The Goods Issue Process Based on the Delivery





      Credit Control

      LIS Reports

      Customized reports

      Text determination

      Account Determination

      Interface between S&D and Financial Accounting

      Copying Control


      Enhancements and Modifications



      Mass Upload Process




      SAP SD Quires

        Transaction and Screen Variants

      I have tried to cover all the SD related topic.

      So when a user tries to search he/she can get the section specific result and that will be very easy to search.

      Along with that I will suggest that SCN should have mobile application where we can search directly from Android/iOS/BlackBerry platform mobile.

      I hope I have given some light on the topic.

      Warm Regards

      Parag Pandya

      Author's profile photo Gabriella Gogl-Gyorgy
      Gabriella Gogl-Gyorgy
      Blog Post Author

      Hi Parag,

      Thank you so much for your kind words!

      I forwarded your explanation to the responsible teams 🙂



      Author's profile photo Richard Harper
      Richard Harper

      Will then be a boxing glove coming out of the screen for inclusion of the word 'URGENT' in the topic title ?? 😡

      Author's profile photo Jürgen Lins
      Jürgen Lins

      while typing "it will trigger a search in the archive for similar topics".

      So the poster will immediately see how many other urgent questions are already in the line in front of him. 😆